Review of Oasis-S Turntable (Early version of the Resolution Classic)
Hi-Fi World Magazine, December 2001
David Price auditions the latest and greatest from Origin Live, the
range topping Oasis S turntable.
While not as well established as John Michell or Ivor Tiefenbrun in the
turntable manufacturing stakes, Mark Baker has been making vinyl spinners
longer than I care to remember. Moreover, hes recently become something
of a legend for his tonearm tweaking process - without his Origin Live
counterweight mod, many impoverished vinyl junkies would be forced to
buy far more expensive pick-up arms!
More than most in hi-fi, hes a man whose ears I have a lot of time
for. He has a forensic knowledge of turntable design, and a clear philosophy
which informs it. Mark believes its all about vibrations - or controlling
them to be precise. This is the key to record deck design because stylus
movements are so incredibly small, and the slightest unwanted motion will
cause colouration. As records are played, a stylus experiences tremendous
acceleration in the record groove, with forces measured in tons per square
inch. This also creates vibration that causes unwanted resonances, if
not properly controlled.
Mark says that what divides a top turntable from an also-ran is how this
unwanted vibration in eliminated. Its an intricate process that
requires clever mechanical engineering solutions - tweaking a couple of
caps in the power supply simply isnt enough! The object of the Oasis-S
is to rotate the record at a constant speed free from this vibration.
This is achieved by extensive use of carefully selected, resonance reducing
materials and matched material interfaces. Components are meticulously
dimensioned, with attention paid to their shape and form (be it solid,
hollow, tubed, or flanged), method of attachment (be it bolting, gluing,
welding, screwing) and decoupling (using springs, spikes, elastic bands,
rubber, foam, air cushion).
The Oasis-S is cleanly styled and exquisitely finished - its just
a shame that its thick, solid wood plinth resembles a number of much older
turntables, from Aristons RD11 to Heybrooks TT2. Scratch the
surface though, and the similarity ends. Most obvious is the translucent
polycarbonate platter, chosen for its close mechanical impedance match
to vinyl. Its more acoustically transparent than the standard issue
Mazak (of the Linn et al), but in the case of the Oasis-S also de-coupled
from an inert sub-platter. The rigid sub-chassis isnt a sprung suspended
design, and instead uses a unique centre point support arrangement which
makes it very easy to set up with nothing to go out of tune.
Origin Live claim that the new 4mm minimal contact ball bearing is extremely
highly toleranced, and runs in high-grade, military specification Arctic
oil. A very quiet, ironless, non-cogging DC motor is used
in preference to the more noisy Impex AC synchronous type found in most
of its rivals.
Its power supply is a regulated, load compensating device claimed to
be stable across a range of temperatures. Speed control is electronically
switched between 33 and 45, while 78 is also available on request.
The supplied arm looks superb in its polished alloy finish. Its
an extensively modified Rega arm thats lost its tapered armtube
and acquired VTA (vertical tracking angle) adjustment, making set up much
easier.
Sound Quality
Thanks to its non-suspended subchassis design, the deck itself is relatively
easy to set up. Just put the (many) bits together, plug in and switch
on. To my eyes, the only let down was the rather crude looking connections
between the turntable and its offboard power supply - two crude bullet
connectors that would look more at home behind a car dashboard. I placed
the deck on my Audiophile Furniture BASE SP-01 sub-table, which is my
preferred support for my regular Michell Orbe (QC) - which served as a
reference. An Ortofon Kontrapunkt B moving coil was fitted.
Essentially, the Oasis S has a tight, clean, even sound with a conspicuous
lack of colouration and overhang. Cueing up High Tensions British
Shuffle on the original Island twelve inch revealed an extremely
detailed and tangible sound. Most impressive was the way it did the hi-fi
start-stop thing with alacrity, whilst still giving real insight
into the textural aspects of the acoustic instruments being played. Bass
guitars assumed a physical presence, rather than being notes playing up
and down a scale - but were never overblown or excessively coloured. Cymbals
were sweet and shimmering, and midband detailing - including the vocals
- was superb. All very natural, beguiling and musical.
Interestingly though, the Oasis-S doesnt sound similar to other
decks that go for the organic approach, such as Linns
LP12. In fact, its closer to the Michell Orbe (Papst AC synchronous
motor version) in its open, analytical, widescreen presentation. Cue up
Randy Crawfords Someday Ill Fly Away and you get
an amazingly vibrant sound, with shimmering timbres from those acoustic
instruments and that sublime voice - from drum kit to keyboards, the whole
recorded acoustic feels alive with atmosphere. In other hi-fi respects
though, the Oasis-S is no less accomplished - best of all were those strongly
articulated images which hung out from the soundstage and were completely
unmoved by other instruments positioned in front and behind them. Factor
in the firecracker dynamics, taut basslines and an infectiously toe-tapping
sense of rhythms and its a powerful performer.
Its best to think of the Oasis-S as a good stab at bringing the
best of both the Linn and Michell sound. Ultimately it betters neither
at their respective fortes, but many vinyl junkies will actually find
it a more sensible option. It lacks both the LP12s hypnotic swing
and the Orbes stunning insight, power and projection, but still
ends up sounding superb. Its very natural, supple and cohesive with
tremendous delicacy and an impeccable sense of timing. It takes you deep
into the music and doesnt preoccupy you with the minutiae of production
and recording details. Rather, it strings
the whole thing together superbly and just cuts to the chase of the music.
As such its superb value - especially considering that brilliant
bundled arm.
Arms and the Man
Mark Baker is the guru of Rega arm mods. This is the fruit of his thinking
- a re-tubed RB250 using a new kind of copper wiring with high-quality
cartridge tags one end and alloy phono plugs the other, and a separate
earth wire terminated at the headshell. The counterweight mounting stub
is modified and locked to the counterweight with a high- tensile Allen
bolt. Origin Live has also added a useful height adjustment for the arm,
courtesy of a sleeve over the mounting pillar. When setting the VTA, OL
recommend tightening this as little as possible, to avoid a bright sound.
Verdict - Brilliantly judged package with tremendous strength indepth.
Not as characterful sounding as its more established rivals, but certainly
none the worse for it. An essential audition.
|